Energy arrow  Sixth Plan arrow  CRAC

Conservation Resources Advisory Committee Meeting
March 12, 2009

Northwest Power and Conservation Council
851 SW Sixth Avenue, Suite 1100
(503) 222-5161

9:30 AM Welcome and Introductions (Tom Eckman)
>> Presentation (110k PowerPoint)
Role of the Committee in the 6th Plan's Development
Proposed 6th Plan Work Plan and Schedule
10:00 AM Conservation Cost-Effectiveness (Eckman)
>> Presentation (720k PowerPoint)

Issue 1 - Should the Council modify its cost-effectiveness methodology?

  • How the Council evaluates resource cost-effectiveness
  • Northwest Energy Efficiency Taskforce (NEET) recommendation
    • Bundling: measure vs. building vs. program vs. portfolio
    • Treatment of non-energy benefits
Issue 2 - Communicating how cost-effectiveness is determined
  • NEET recommendation
  • Prepare and distribute: "Cost-Effectiveness for Dummies"
12:00 PM Lunch - on your own
1:15 PM Constraints on Conservation Acceleration and Sustained Annual Acquisition Levels (Charles Grist)
>> Presentation (1mb PowerPoint)

Issue 1 - What "ramp rates" should be assumed for maximum achievable market penetration during the next five years?

  • 5th Plan assumptions
  • Proposed assumptions for 6th Plan
Issue 2 - What should be assumed as the maximum achievable market penetration over the entire planning period (20 years)?
  • 5th Plan assumptions
  • Proposed assumptions for 6th Plan
3:30 PM Adjourn
Background Materials:
>> NEET Workgroup 6 Recommendations on Cost-Effectiveness (180k Word)
>> California Standard Practices Manual for Cost-Effectiveness (1mb PDF)
>> Misconceptions, Mistakes, and Misnomers in DSM Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (3.5mb PDF)
>> Council Issue Paper on Conservation Cost-Effectiveness (40k PDF)
>> Council Issue Paper on Achievable Potential (200k PDF)