nwcouncil.org home    

Public comments on Mainstem Passage Strategies report (aka "Giorgi Report")

space

Public comments were solicited for Dr. Al Giorgi's Mainstem Passage Strategies report through March 8, 2002. These are the comments received:

Idaho Water Users (150k PDF)
Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks (480k PDF)
National Marine Fisheries Service (390k PDF)
Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife (1.2m PDF)
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (800k PDF)
Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (20k PDF)

Columbia River Indian People of the Salmon

Comment 1: "The Mid-Columbia River indian people of the Yakamas would like to request our 50% share of the harvestable salmon for this spring season as per 88 court order of the Columbia River Fish Management Plan. We would like to be placed on your mailing list and be able to make oral presentations. Thanks, Columbia River Indian People of the Salmon."

Comment 2: "I would recommend you speak with Chief Jonny Jackson of the Cascade Tribes. He may be reached at 509-493-2608. He can give your group some valuable information as to the salmon on the Columbia River. We would appreciate your assistance for an open discussion as to our fisheries and/or treaty rights on the Columbia River. Thanks, Simon Sampson, 509-865-5104."

James Williams

"I believe that further study on healthy fish habitat should be implemented on an emergency basis. Fish runs in inland screams and all the environmental extensions resulting therefrom are more valuable both monetarily and culturally than dams and hydroelectricity. Our ecosystem's health hundreds of years from now is more valuable that silted in dams and vanished species. James F. Williams 3050 Beech AV Billings, MT 59102."

Stephen Pauley, MD

"Since you can't act directly, at least recommend the following:

  • Barging does not work so let the fish spill.
  • Stop giving precedence to BPA's needs.
  • Increase river flows per your obligations under the Clean Water Act and the ESA.
  • Stop flooding the system with hatchery fish. It dilutes the gene pool of the natives and introduces diseases.
  • Be honest when reporting your adult counts. Let the public know hatchery vs wild returns.
  • Educate the public on SAR's for NATIVES and what SAR is needed for natives to survive.
  • Obey the laws under which the NWPPC was established.
  • Give equal say to fish and stop protecting big ag & BPA over fish survival.

You are not doing your jobs as defined under the NW Power Act. Please start. Thank you, Stephen M Pauley MD, Box 3759, Ketchum, ID."

^ top

Get Acrobat Reader Documents in Acrobat PDF format
require the Acrobat reader plugin