Skip to main content

Header Menu

  • Contact

Search

Menu
  • About

    Integrating energy and the environment in the Columbia River Basin

    About the Council
    • Mission and Strategy
    • Members and Staff
    • Bylaws
    • Policies
    • Careers / RFPs
  • News

    See what the Council is up to.

    Read the latest news
    • Read All News
    • Press Resources
    • Newsletters
    • International Columbia River

    Explore News by Topic

    • Fish and Wildlife Planning
    • Salmon and Steelhead
    • Wildlife
    • Energy Planning
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Demand Response
  • Fish and Wildlife

    The Council works to protect and enhance fish and wildlife in the Columbia River Basin. Its Fish & Wildlife Program guides project funding by the Bonneville Power Administration.

    Fish & Wildlife overview

    The Fish and Wildlife Program

    • 2020 Addendum
    • 2014/2020 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program
    • Subbasin Plans
    • Project Reviews and Recommendations

    Independent Review Groups

    • Independent Economic Analysis Board (IEAB)
    • Independent Scientific Advisory Board (ISAB)
    • Independent Scientific Review Panel (ISRP)

    Forums and Workgroups

    • Asset Management Subcommittee
    • Ocean and Plume Science and Management Forum
    • Regional Coordination
    • Science and Policy Exchange
    • Toxics Workgroup
    • Columbia Basin Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Workgroup
    • Informal Hatchery Workgroup

    Topics

    • Adaptive Management
    • Anadromous Fish Mitigation
    • Blocked Areas
    • High-level Indicators
    • Invasive and Non-Native Species
    • Lamprey
    • Predation
    • Protected Areas
    • Research Plan
    • Resource Tools and Maps
    • Sea Lions
    • Sockeye
    • Sturgeon
    • The Pike Problem
    • Hatchery Map
  • Energy

    The Council develops a plan, updated every five years, to ensure the region’s power supply and acquire cost-effective energy efficiency.

    Energy overview

    THE NORTHWEST POWER PLAN

    • The 2021 Northwest Power Plan
    • The Seventh Power Plan
    • Planning Process and Past Power Plans

    TECHNICAL TOOLS AND MODELS

    • Regional Portfolio Model
    • Generation Evaluation System Model (GENESYS)

    Energy Advisory Committees

    • Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Demand Forecast Advisory Committee
    • Demand Response Advisory Committee
    • Generating Resources Advisory Committee
    • Natural Gas Advisory Committee
    • Resource Adequacy Advisory Committee
    • System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Regional Technical Forum
    • RTF Policy Advisory Committee
    • System Integration Forum
    • Resource Strategies Advisory Committee (Not Active)

    Energy Topics

    • Energy Efficiency
    • Demand Response
    • Power Supply
    • Resource Adequacy
    • Energy Storage
    • Hydropower

    Energy Forums and Workgroups

    • Pacific NW Demand Response Project
    • Northwest Wind Integration Forum (Archive)
  • Meetings
    See next Council meeting February 9 - 10, 2021 in TBA or webinar › See all meetings ›

    View all council meetings View full calendar

    Recent and Upcoming Meetings

    Previous Swipe left or right Next
    • Aug 2020 Wed 05
      9:30 am—3:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee Webinar
    • Aug 2020 Tue Wed 11 - 12
      Council Meeting
    • Aug 2020 Tue 18
      9:00 am—1:00 pm RTF Meeting: August 18, 2020
    • Sep 2020 Wed 02
      9:30 am—3:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Sep 2020 Wed Thu 09 - 10
      RTF Meeting: September 9, 2020
    • Sep 2020 Thu 10
      10:00 am—11:00 am Informal Hatchery Workgroup Meeting
    • Sep 2020 Tue Wed 15 - 16
      Council Meeting
    • Sep 2020 Fri 25
      9:30 am—11:00 am RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting
    • Sep 2020 Tue 29
      9:00 am—1:00 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Sep 2020 Wed 30
      9:30 am—12:30 pm Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Oct 2020 Thu 01
      9:30 am—12:30 pm Power Committee Webinar
    • Oct 2020 Tue Wed 06 - 07
      RTF Meeting: October 6, 2020
    • Oct 2020 Tue 06
      1:30 pm—4:00 pm Resource Adequacy - Technical Committee
    • Oct 2020 Wed 07
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Oct 2020 Mon Wed 12 - 14
      Council Meeting
    • Oct 2020 Thu 22
      1:00 pm—4:00 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Oct 2020 Fri 23
      9:00 am—10:30 am Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Oct 2020 Tue 27
      10:00 am—12:30 pm Demand Response Advisory Committee
    • Nov 2020 Wed 04
      9:30 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Nov 2020 Tue 10
      9:00 am—1:30 pm RTF Meeting: November 10, 2020
    • Nov 2020 Tue Wed 17 - 18
      Council Meeting
    • Nov 2020 Mon 30
      1:00 pm—4:00 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Dec 2020 Tue 01
      9:00 am—12:00 pm Resource Adequacy - Technical Committee
    • Dec 2020 Wed 02
      9:30 am—11:00 am Generating Resources Advisory Committee
    • Dec 2020 Thu 03
      9:00 am—11:00 am Power Committee Webinar
    • Dec 2020 Tue 08
      9:00 am—1:00 pm RTF Meeting: December 8, 2020
    • Dec 2020 Wed 09
      9:00 am—11:00 am RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting 9:30 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee 10:00 am—12:00 pm Informal Hatchery Workgroup Meeting
    • Dec 2020 Fri 11
      9:30 am—11:30 am Resource Adequacy - Steering Committee
    • Dec 2020 Tue Wed 15 - 16
      Council Meeting
    • Dec 2020 Thu 17
      9:00 am—12:00 pm Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Jan 2021 Fri 08
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis and Resource Adequacy Combined Committee Meeting
    • Jan 2021 Tue Wed 12 - 13
      Council Meeting
    • Jan 2021 Tue 19
      1:00 pm—4:00 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Jan 2021 Wed 20
      9:00 am—1:00 pm RTF Meeting: January 20, 2021
    • Jan 2021 Thu 21
      9:00 am—12:00 pm Regional Coordination Forum
    • Jan 2021 Tue 26
      9:00 am—12:00 pm Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Jan 2021 Thu 28
      8:30 am—11:30 am Power Committee Webinar
    • Feb 2021 Wed 03
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Feb 2021 Mon 08
      1:00 pm—4:00 pm Demand Response Advisory Committee
    • Feb 2021 Tue Wed 09 - 10
      Council Meeting
    • Feb 2021 Wed Thu 17 - 18
      RTF Meeting: February 17-18, 2021
    • Feb 2021 Wed 17
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Feb 2021 Fri 19
      9:00 am—3:30 pm SIF: 2021 Power Plan and DEI
    • Feb 2021 Wed 24
      8:30 am—11:30 am Power Committee Webinar
    • Feb 2021 Thu 25
      9:00 am—12:00 pm Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
    • Mar 2021 Wed 03
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Mar 2021 Tue Wed 09 - 10
      Council Meeting
    • Mar 2021 Tue Wed 16 - 17
      RTF Meeting: March 16-17, 2021
    • Mar 2021 Wed 17
      9:00 am—12:30 pm System Analysis Advisory Committee
    • Mar 2021 Fri 19
      9:00 am—3:00 pm RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting
    • Mar 2021 Wed 24
      8:30 am—11:30 am Power Committee Webinar
    • Apr 2021 Tue Wed 06 - 07
      Council Meeting
    • Apr 2021 Tue Wed 13 - 14
      RTF Meeting: April 13-14, 2021
    • Apr 2021 Wed 21
      8:30 am—11:30 am Power Committee Webinar
    • May 2021 Tue Wed 04 - 05
      Council Meeting
    • May 2021 Tue Wed 11 - 12
      RTF Meeting: May 11-12, 2021
    • May 2021 Wed 26
      8:30 am—11:30 am Power Committee Webinar
    • Jun 2021 Wed 02
      1:00 pm—4:00 pm RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting
    • Jun 2021 Tue Wed 08 - 09
      Council Meeting
    • Jun 2021 Tue Wed 15 - 16
      RTF Meeting: June 15-16, 2021
    • Jul 2021 Tue Wed 13 - 14
      Council Meeting
    • Jul 2021 Tue Wed 20 - 21
      RTF Meeting: July 20-21, 2021
    View Council Meetings View all Meetings
  • Reports and Documents

    Browse reports and documents relevant to the Council's work on fish and wildlife and energy planning, as well as administrative reports.

    Browse reports

    Reports by Topic

    • Power Plan
    • Fish and Wildlife Program
    • Subbasin Plans
    • Financial Reports
    • Independent Scientific Advisory Board
    • Independent Scientific Review Panel
    • Independent Economic Analysis Board

    Columbia River History Project

Close

Tough Task

Use the Council's methodology to determine when new power plants are needed, not an arbitrary standard, departing Chair urges.

January 16, 2018
John Harrison

Share

On his last day as Chair of the Northwest Power and Conservation Council, Henry Lorenzen, a Pendleton rancher and attorney with a long history in regional energy and environmental issues, warned that decisions about future regional energy supplies are being made with more attention to meeting goals or targets than whether the energy actually is needed.

“We, the Council, exist because the region committed a major error with regard to resources to be acquired, WPPSS 1 through 5, and it had a dramatic impact and it continues to have a dramatic impact upon ratepayers and the Bonneville Power Administration’s competitiveness,” Lorenzen said, referring to the 1970s decision to build five nuclear power plants, only one of which was completed. The debt for three of those plants continues as a Bonneville obligation, amounting to nearly $300 million in 2017. Lorenzen's verbatim remarks follow this post.

In response, Lorenzen said, the Council developed “a more rigorous methodology with regard to planning resources.” With this methodology, the Council “determines the least-cost, least-financial-risk resources in order to meet needs based on probabilistic modeling, taking into account a wide range of variables.”

The Council’s Seventh Northwest Power Plan, completed in 2015, included a careful analysis of the best mix of future power supplies that would meet anticipated demand and keep electricity affordable and the supply reliable far into the future. Resources in the plan were, in priority order, energy efficiency, demand response, and a limited number of new natural gas fired plants. The plan called for developing renewable resources to the extent required by state standards. The power plan is implemented by Bonneville and is used by electric utilities as a guide in their own least-cost planning.

Lorenzen said this careful approach to minimize risk, including the financial risk of paying for power plants that are not needed, is not being used in political decisions to set renewable energy goals.

“Very shortly after the release of our Power Plan, decisions were made to substantially increase our renewable energy resources within the Northwest, and that was done by the legislature and other political activities,” he said. “And as a result I’m not certain whether our methodologies we’ve developed are in fact being taken into account to the extent they should be when resource decisions are being made.”

Lorenzen said the challenge for the future is “to make certain to the best we can that the methodologies that we have developed also are taken into consideration by those entities, those persons who are making those decisions, whether it be the traditional utility managers or the legislators.”

He said it will be “a tough task” because the issues are complicated. He predicted it will be necessary to bring the same rigor to decisions about environmental protection, including carbon reduction.

“By doing so we marshal our resources and we achieve a greater good, I believe, ultimately with regard to these matters that are so critically important,” Lorenzen said.

---------------------------------------------------

January 10, 2018 

Remarks of Chair Henry Lorenzen

Northwest Power and Conservation Council Meeting

January 10, 2018 – Portland, Oregon

Now I’m going to have the opportunity to talk before we go. I still control the gavel and I control it for however long I’m willing to talk and people are willing to listen.

I want to mention just a couple of things I perceive as trends that I think have a significant impact upon what the Council does and its work in the future.  Going back to 1980, we are here and we exist as a Council and the Act was passed because the region had made a major error, committed a major error in decisions with regard to resources to be acquired.  WPPSS Plants 1 through 5.  It had a dramatic impact and it continues to have a dramatic impact upon ratepayers and the Bonneville Power Administration’s competitiveness.  The Act anticipated that we would exist and we would have a staff and a mission to develop a more rigorous methodology with regard to planning resources for the area. Over the last many years our staff, an incredibly capable staff, has developed a state-of-the-art methodology by which to anticipate and determine the least-cost, least financial risk resources in order to meet needs based upon probabilistic modeling, taking into account a wide variety and wide range of variables.

My concern is that as we’ve moved forward and we have developed these very rigorous models that have been recognized as state of the art, the traditional people and entities making decisions with regard to acquisition of resources are no longer doing so.  As a result, I’m not certain whether the methodologies we’ve developed are in fact being taken into account to the extent they should be when resource decisions are being made.  If you look back at our Power Plan, the 7th Power Plan, the conclusion was very stark with regard to additional renewable resources necessary in order to meet the Obama Clean Power Plan regionally.  But very shortly after the release of our Power Plan, decisions were made to substantially increase renewables that were to be developed within the Northwest. That was done by the legislature and through other political activities. 

Our challenge, I believe, is to make certain in the future, to the best we can, that the methodologies that we have developed also are taken into consideration by those entities, those persons who are making those decisions, whether it be the traditional utility managers or the legislators. 

That’s a tough task because this is a complicated area. These are complicated matters. On the surface it sounds as if many of us are not concerned about carbon. I am one who is very concerned about environmental issues, very concerned about carbon. But we have to bring the same methodology that we used in planning for generating resources into the area of environmental protection, including carbon reduction.  By doing so we marshal our resources and we achieve a greater good, I believe, ultimately with regard to these matters that are so critically important. 

Another thing, just a tangential matter, has to do with carbon reduction.  I was very struck by Steve Wright’s presentation to us when he complimented us, which is always nice to have a compliment from somebody like Steve Wright, on the methodology used for developing the resource acquisition analysis in the 7th Power Plan. But he then lamented the fact that we were not using the same rigor in looking at how to go about reducing carbon. Our Council staff has methodologies, used in the 7th Power Plan, available to assist those who are making resource and carbon-related decisions.  The question is how do we go about making the inter-connect with those people that are doing the decision making? 

That’s my caution, my look forward.  I hope that the Council can determine how to be successful in promoting and also making our tools available and used by the whole range of people who make those decisions with regard to power planning as well as carbon reduction.

So, with that, my parting shot, I will now soon give up the gavel.

Topics: 
Energy
Tags: 
Power planning Renewable resources

Related News

Jan 3, 2021

State of Northwest Utilities in 2019

Flat load growth continues and on site solar takes off.

Read full story
Dec 16, 2020

Clean air, affordable power and environmental mitigation: Northwest Power Act turns 40

Four decades ago, legislators and policymakers in the Pacific Northwest took a revolutionary leap of faith, writing a law that changed the direction of the region's energy future and made fish and wildlife co-equal with other purposes of hydropower dams in the Columbia River Basin.

Read full story
Dec 4, 2020

Wholesale Electricity Prices Come Into Focus

Throughout the West, retiring coal plants and a plethora of clean energy policies in states, municipalities, and utilities have changed how electricity markets function, adding even more uncertainty to an already challenging enterprise: forecasting the future.

Read full story
Oct 20, 2020

Could California’s Summer Rolling Blackouts Happen in the Northwest?

Could the Northwest experience rolling blackouts? “Yes,” says John Fazio, senior power systems analyst. “And it almost happened in 2001.”

Read full story

Sign up for our Newsletter

Contact

  • Central Office
  • Idaho Office
  • Montana Office
  • Oregon Office
  • Washington Office
  • Council Members

Social Media:

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn Vimeo Flickr

Copyright 2021

Footer Menu

  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Top