Contact
About

Integrating energy and the environment in the Columbia River Basin

About the Council
Mission and Strategy Members and Staff Bylaws Policies Careers / RFPs
News

See what the Council is up to.

Read the Latest News
Read All News Press Resources Newsletters International Columbia River

Explore News By Topic

Fish and Wildlife Planning Salmon and Steelhead Wildlife Energy Planning Energy Efficiency Demand Response
Fish and Wildlife

The Council works to protect and enhance fish and wildlife in the Columbia River Basin. Its Fish & Wildlife Program guides project funding by the Bonneville Power Administration.

Fish and Wildlife Overview

The Fish and Wildlife Program

2020 Addendum 2014/2020 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Subbasin Plans Project Reviews and Recommendations

Independent Review Groups

  • Independent Economic Analysis Board (IEAB)
  • Independent Scientific Advisory Board (ISAB)
  • Independent Scientific Review Panel (ISRP)

Forums and Workgroups

  • Asset Management Subcommittee
  • Ocean and Plume Science and Management Forum
  • Regional Coordination
  • Science and Policy Exchange
  • Toxics Workgroup
  • Columbia Basin Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Workgroup
  • Informal Hatchery Workgroup
  • Strategy Performance Indicator Workgroup

Topics

  • Adaptive Management
  • Anadromous Fish Mitigation
  • Blocked Areas
  • High-level Indicators
  • Invasive and Non-Native Species
  • Lamprey
  • Predation: Sea lions, pike, birds
  • Protected Areas
  • Research Plan
  • Resident Fish
  • Resource Tools and Maps
  • Sockeye
  • Sturgeon
  • Hatchery Map
Energy

The Council develops a plan, updated every five years, to ensure the region’s power supply and acquire cost-effective energy efficiency.

Energy Overview

The Northwest Power Plan

The 2021 Northwest Power Plan 2021 Plan Supporting Materials Planning Process and Past Power Plans

Technical Tools and Models

  • Regional Portfolio Model
  • Generation Evaluation System Model (GENESYS)

Energy Advisory Committees

  • Regional Technical Forum
  • Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
  • Demand Forecast Advisory Committee
  • Demand Response Advisory Committee
  • Generating Resources Advisory Committee
  • Fuels Advisory Committee
  • Resource Adequacy Advisory Committee
  • System Analysis Advisory Committee
  • RTF Policy Advisory Committee
  • System Integration Forum

Energy Topics

  • Energy Efficiency
  • Demand Response
  • Power Supply
  • Resource Adequacy
  • Energy Storage
  • Hydropower
  • Transmission
Meetings
See next Council Meeting April 11 - 12, 2023 in (Webinar) › See all meetings ›

Recent and Upcoming Meetings

Swipe left or right
JUL 2022
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
JUL 2022
TUE
19
9:00 am—3:00 pm
RTF Meeting
JUL 2022
WED
27
9:30 am—3:30 pm
Resource Adequacy and System Analysis Committee Meeting
AUG 2022
TUE
09
9:00 am—12:45 pm
RTF Meeting
AUG 2022
WED
10
9:00 am—12:00 pm
System Analysis Advisory Committee
AUG 2022
TUE WED
16 - 17
Council Meeting
AUG 2022
TUE
30
9:00 am—11:00 am
F&W Committee Meeting
AUG 2022
WED
31
9:00 am—12:00 pm
System Analysis Advisory Committee
SEP 2022
MON
12
9:00 am—12:00 pm
Strategy Performance Indicator Workgroup Meeting
SEP 2022
TUE WED
13 - 14
Council Meeting
SEP 2022
TUE
20
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
SEP 2022
WED
21
9:00 am—12:00 pm
Resource Adequacy Adv Comm - Tech Committee
SEP 2022
WED
28
9:00 am—10:00 am
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q3 Meeting
SEP 2022
THU
29
9:00 am—12:00 pm
System Analysis Advisory Committee
OCT 2022
TUE WED
04 - 05
F&W and Power Committee Meetings
OCT 2022
TUE
11
9:00 am—1:00 pm
Council Meeting
OCT 2022
TUE
18
9:00 am—12:00 pm
RTF Meeting
NOV 2022
WED
02
9:30 am—12:00 pm
Demand Response Advisory Committee
NOV 2022
THU
03
9:30 am—3:30 pm
GENESYS Technical Conference (SAAC/RAAC Combined)
NOV 2022
TUE
08
1:00 pm—4:00 pm
Resource Adequacy Technical/Steering Comm Meetings
NOV 2022
TUE WED
15 - 16
Council Meeting
NOV 2022
WED
30
9:00 am—10:00 am
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q4 Meeting
DEC 2022
MON
05
1:30 pm—3:30 pm
Resource Adequacy Advisory Committee
DEC 2022
TUE
06
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
DEC 2022
TUE WED
13 - 14
Council Meeting
JAN 2023
TUE WED
10 - 11
Council Meeting
JAN 2023
WED
18
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
FEB 2023
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
FEB 2023
WED
22
2:00 pm—3:30 pm
Conservation Resources/Demand Response Adv Comm Combined Meeting
FEB 2023
WED THU
22 - 23
RTF Meeting
FEB 2023
FRI
24
9:00 am—2:00 pm
Conservation Resources Advisory Comm.
MAR 2023
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
MAR 2023
TUE
21
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
MAR 2023
THU
23
9:00 am—12:00 pm
Resource Adequacy Adv Comm - Technical Committee
MAR 2023
TUE
28
9:00 am—11:00 am
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q1 Meeting
MAR 2023
FRI
31
9:00 am—10:30 am
Generating Resources Advisory Committee
APR 2023
WED
05
9:00 am—12:00 pm
System Analysis Advisory Committee
APR 2023
MON
10
1:00 pm—4:00 pm
Regional Coordination Forum (RCF) Meeting
APR 2023
TUE WED
11 - 12
Council Meeting
APR 2023
TUE WED
18 - 19
RTF Meeting
MAY 2023
TUE WED
16 - 17
Council Meeting
MAY 2023
TUE
23
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
MAY 2023
WED
24
12:30 pm—3:30 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q2 Meeting
JUN 2023
TUE WED
13 - 14
Council Meeting
JUN 2023
WED THU
21 - 22
RTF Meeting June 21-22, 2023
JUL 2023
TUE WED
11 - 12
Council Meeting
JUL 2023
TUE
18
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
AUG 2023
TUE WED
15 - 16
Council Meeting
AUG 2023
TUE WED
22 - 23
RTF Meeting
SEP 2023
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
SEP 2023
FRI
15
9:00 am—12:00 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q3 Meeting
SEP 2023
TUE
19
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
OCT 2023
WED THU
11 - 12
Council Meeting
OCT 2023
TUE WED
17 - 18
RTF Meeting
NOV 2023
TUE
07
9:00 am—1:00 pm
RTF Meeting
NOV 2023
WED
08
12:30 pm—3:30 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q4 Meeting
NOV 2023
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
DEC 2023
TUE
05
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
DEC 2023
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
View Council Meetings View All Meetings
Reports and Documents

Browse reports and documents relevant to the Council's work on fish and wildlife and energy planning, as well as administrative reports.

Browse Reports

REPORTS BY TOPIC

Power Plan Fish and Wildlife Program Subbasin Plans Financial Reports Independent Scientific Advisory Board Independent Scientific Review Panel Independent Economic Analysis Board

COLUMBIA RIVER HISTORY PROJECT

ISAB Comparison of Research Findings on Avian Predation Impacts on Salmon Survival

Council Document Number: 
ISAB 2021-2
Published date: 
April 23, 2021
Document state: 
Published

Share

Columbia Basin fish and wildlife managers, policy makers, and researchers have expressed concern about differences in the conclusions and management implications of the following two publications on Columbia River Basin steelhead trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): Avian predation on steelhead is consistent with compensatory mortality (Haeseker et al. 2020) and Measuring the additive effects of predation on prey survival across spatial scales (Payton et. al 2020).

Significant questions remain about the extent to which avian predation is additive or compensatory. At their extremes, (completely) additive means that changes in predation are reflected one-to-one in changes in the overall survival, whereas (completely) compensatory means that other life cycle factors operate to negate or counteract the effects of predation so that long-term survival is unaffected by the predation in question. More often in nature, mixtures of additivity and compensation are observed rather than the extremes of complete additivity or compensation (Haeseker et al. 2020; Payton et. al 2020). Results of analyses examining compensatory versus additivity in survival, such as the Haeseker et al. and Payton et al. papers, can strongly affect decisions about future regional management actions designed to reduce avian fish predators (i.e., hazing, re-locating, culling, etc.).

This ISAB report evaluates similarities and differences in data, analytical approaches, conclusions, and management implications of the two studies of avian predation on juvenile steelhead in the Columbia River Basin. Both studies focused on determining whether the effects of avian predation on overall survival were additive or compensatory. Haeseker et al. (2020) focused on bird predation in the Columbia River estuary of migrating smolts from the Snake River Basin and its effect on survivorship (return probability) of adults returning to Bonneville Dam. Haeseker et al. concluded that mortality from avian predation was consistent with full compensation.

In contrast, Payton et al. (2020) estimated the effects of bird predation both in the river and in the estuary on Upper Columbia Basin smolts at two life stages: from release at Rock Island Dam to Bonneville Dam as smolts, and from release to adult return to Bonneville Dam. Payton et al. concluded that predation mortality was super-additive for smolts between Rock Island and Bonneville, and partially additive from release to adult return to Bonneville Dam. Super-additive means causing more smolts to die than the number of smolts estimated to be consumed by bird predators. Sources for additional undetected mortality include deposition of PIT tags at locations other than the colony, smolts being stolen by gulls, wounding or injury that results in mortality but not capture by the predator, or consumption by birds that occupy areas other than the colonies monitored for PIT tags.

While the studies were conducted in different basins and employed only partially overlapping time series, the ISAB compared data and analyses from migration to adult return life stage to illuminate the nature of conclusions and interpretations. The ISAB concludes that despite these differences, the two studies are not inconsistent in their results.

Both studies looked at mortality during the estuarine/marine phase and concluded that predation is either largely (Payton et al.) or fully (Haeseker et al.) compensatory. Only Payton et al. assessed smolt survival during in-river migration, and there appears to be strong additivity of predation this life history phase. Results of both studies are consistent with the possibility of low-level partial additivity of predation effects on smolt-to-adult returns (SAR). For populations at risk, avian predation that is partially additive could affect population sustainability. Additional analyses and studies are needed to fully evaluate the relative importance of avian predation in a population conservation context.

A major question for management is whether an increase in SARs is worth the cost of suppressing avian predators or is critical to the support of ESA-listed salmonid species. Answering these questions requires estimates of the magnitude of avian predation effects rather than estimates of the degree of additivity or compensation, and also requires consideration of social concerns, cost effectiveness, and ecosystem consequences of avian control actions (ISAB 2019-1). Reconciling results from these studies in a side-by-side analysis, evaluating additional methods for obtaining predation effect size from tagging data, and incorporating these into life cycle models for different species and populations are the next steps toward understanding how avian predation fits into broader management strategies and goals for Columbia Basin salmonids. Until these additional steps can be implemented, the ISAB recommends that the finding of partial additivity/partial compensation over the entire life cycle of steelhead is the most prudent conclusion from a management perspective.

Topics: 
Fish and wildlife
Tags: 
Fish Passage CenterSalmon and SteelheadPredationColumbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife ProgramNOAA FisheriesDouble-crested CormorantColumbia River Inter-Tribal Fish CommissionAvianPredator ManagementHydrosystemCaspian TernISABAnadromous Fish MitigationStatistical DesignLife-cycle ModelDensity Dependence

ISRP 2021-05 LibbyMFWPfollow-up1June.pdf

Download the full report

Sign up for our newsletter

  •    

Contact

  • Central Office
  • Idaho Office
  • Montana Office
  • Oregon Office
  • Washington Office
  • Council Members

Social Media:

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn Vimeo Flickr

Copyright 2022

Privacy policy Terms & Conditions