Contact
About

Integrating energy and the environment in the Columbia River Basin

About the Council
Mission and Strategy Members and Staff Bylaws Policies Careers / RFPs
News

See what the Council is up to.

Read the Latest News
Read All News Press Resources Newsletters International Columbia River

Explore News By Topic

Fish and Wildlife Planning Salmon and Steelhead Wildlife Energy Planning Energy Efficiency Demand Response
Fish and Wildlife

The Council works to protect and enhance fish and wildlife in the Columbia River Basin. Its Fish & Wildlife Program guides project funding by the Bonneville Power Administration.

Fish and Wildlife Overview

The Fish and Wildlife Program

2020 Addendum 2014/2020 Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program Subbasin Plans Project Reviews and Recommendations

Independent Review Groups

  • Independent Economic Analysis Board (IEAB)
  • Independent Scientific Advisory Board (ISAB)
  • Independent Scientific Review Panel (ISRP)

Forums and Workgroups

  • Asset Management Subcommittee
  • Ocean and Plume Science and Management Forum
  • Regional Coordination
  • Science and Policy Exchange
  • Toxics Workgroup
  • Columbia Basin Research, Monitoring and Evaluation Workgroup
  • Informal Hatchery Workgroup
  • Strategy Performance Indicator Workgroup

Topics

  • Adaptive Management
  • Anadromous Fish Mitigation
  • Blocked Areas
  • High-level Indicators
  • Invasive and Non-Native Species
  • Lamprey
  • Predation: Sea lions, pike, birds
  • Protected Areas
  • Research Plan
  • Resident Fish
  • Resource Tools and Maps
  • Sockeye
  • Sturgeon
  • Hatchery Map
Energy

The Council develops a plan, updated every five years, to ensure the region’s power supply and acquire cost-effective energy efficiency.

Energy Overview

The Northwest Power Plan

The 2021 Northwest Power Plan 2021 Plan Supporting Materials Planning Process and Past Power Plans

Technical Tools and Models

  • Regional Portfolio Model
  • Generation Evaluation System Model (GENESYS)

Energy Advisory Committees

  • Regional Technical Forum
  • Conservation Resources Advisory Committee
  • Demand Forecast Advisory Committee
  • Demand Response Advisory Committee
  • Generating Resources Advisory Committee
  • Natural Gas Advisory Committee
  • Resource Adequacy Advisory Committee
  • System Analysis Advisory Committee
  • RTF Policy Advisory Committee
  • System Integration Forum
  • Resource Strategies Advisory Committee (Not Active)

Energy Topics

  • Energy Efficiency
  • Demand Response
  • Power Supply
  • Resource Adequacy
  • Energy Storage
  • Hydropower
  • Transmission

Energy Forums and Workgroups

  • Pacific NW Demand Response Project
  • Northwest Wind Integration Forum (Archive)
Meetings
See next F&W Committee Meeting and Council Meeting July 06 - 07, 2022 in Webinar › See all meetings ›

Recent and Upcoming Meetings

Swipe left or right
AUG 2021
TUE
31
9:00 am—2:45 pm
RTF Meeting
SEP 2021
MON
13
9:00 am—12:00 pm
Strategy Performance Indicator Workgroup
SEP 2021
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
SEP 2021
TUE
21
10:00 am—11:00 am
Informal Hatchery Workgroup Meeting
SEP 2021
TUE WED
21 - 22
RTF Meeting
SEP 2021
MON
27
Power Plan Public Hearing Hosted by Montana
SEP 2021
WED
29
9:00 am—11:30 am
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting
OCT 2021
THU
07
Power Plan Public Hearing Hosted by Washington
OCT 2021
TUE
12
Power Plan Public Hearing Hosted by Oregon
OCT 2021
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
OCT 2021
THU
14
Power Plan Public Hearing Hosted by Idaho
OCT 2021
TUE
19
9:30 am—3:00 pm
RTF Meeting
NOV 2021
TUE
09
9:00 am—1:00 pm
RTF Meeting
NOV 2021
TUE WED
16 - 17
Council Meeting
NOV 2021
TUE
30
1:00 pm—3:00 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Meeting
DEC 2021
TUE WED
07 - 08
RTF Meeting
DEC 2021
MON
13
9:00 am—11:00 am
Strategy Performance Indicator Workgroup
DEC 2021
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
JAN 2022
TUE WED
11 - 12
Council Meeting
JAN 2022
WED
19
1:00 pm—5:00 pm
Ocean and Plume Science and Management Forum
JAN 2022
TUE
25
9:00 am—12:00 pm
RTF New Member Orientation: January 25, 2022
JAN 2022
WED
26
9:00 am—1:00 pm
RTF Meeting
JAN 2022
FRI
28
8:30 am—11:30 am
Power Committee Meeting
FEB 2022
MON
14
9:00 am—10:30 am
Informal Hatchery Workgroup Meeting
FEB 2022
TUE WED
15 - 16
Council Meeting
FEB 2022
WED
23
9:00 am—2:30 pm
RTF Meeting
MAR 2022
WED
02
9:30 am—3:00 pm
System Integration Forum: Scope of Work on Potential Lower Snake River Dam Analysis
MAR 2022
TUE
08
1:30 pm—2:30 pm
Public Affairs Committee Meeting
MAR 2022
MON TUE
14 - 15
Council Meeting
MAR 2022
FRI
18
9:00 am—11:00 am
Fish and Wildlife Committee Meeting
MAR 2022
TUE WED
22 - 23
RTF Meeting
MAR 2022
WED
30
9:30 am—12:00 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q1 Meeting
APR 2022
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
APR 2022
TUE WED
19 - 20
RTF Meeting
MAY 2022
TUE WED
10 - 11
F&W and Power Committee Meetings
MAY 2022
WED
18
Council Meeting
MAY 2022
TUE
24
9:00 am—2:30 pm
RTF Meeting
JUN 2022
WED
08
1:00 pm—3:30 pm
System Analysis Advisory Committee
9:30 am—11:30 am
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q2 Meeting
JUN 2022
TUE WED
14 - 15
Council Meeting
JUN 2022
WED
22
9:00 am—2:00 pm
RTF Meeting
JUL 2022
WED THU
06 - 07
F&W Committee Meeting and Council Meeting
JUL 2022
FRI
08
9:00 am—10:30 am
Resource Adequacy Adv Comm - Steering Committee
JUL 2022
TUE WED
12 - 13
Council Meeting
JUL 2022
TUE
19
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
JUL 2022
WED
27
9:30 am—3:30 pm
Resource Adequacy and System Analysis Committee Meeting
AUG 2022
TUE
09
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
AUG 2022
TUE WED
16 - 17
Council Meeting
SEP 2022
TUE WED
13 - 14
Council Meeting
SEP 2022
TUE WED
20 - 21
RTF Meeting
SEP 2022
WED
28
9:00 am—12:00 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q3 Meeting
OCT 2022
TUE WED
04 - 05
F&W and Power Committee Meetings
OCT 2022
TUE WED
11 - 12
Council Meeting
OCT 2022
TUE WED
18 - 19
RTF Meeting
NOV 2022
TUE
08
9:00 am—4:00 pm
RTF Meeting
NOV 2022
TUE WED
15 - 16
Council Meeting
NOV 2022
WED
30
9:00 am—12:00 pm
RTF Policy Advisory Committee Q4 Meeting
DEC 2022
TUE WED
06 - 07
RTF Meeting
DEC 2022
TUE WED
13 - 14
Council Meeting
View Council Meetings View All Meetings
Reports and Documents

Browse reports and documents relevant to the Council's work on fish and wildlife and energy planning, as well as administrative reports.

Browse Reports

REPORTS BY TOPIC

Power Plan Fish and Wildlife Program Subbasin Plans Financial Reports Independent Scientific Advisory Board Independent Scientific Review Panel Independent Economic Analysis Board

COLUMBIA RIVER HISTORY PROJECT

Review of the Comparative Survival Study (CSS) Draft 2014 Annual Report

Council Document Number: 
ISAB 2014-5
Published date: 
Oct. 14, 2014
Document state: 
Published

Share

Note: The original ISAB report dated October 14, 2014 was updated October 29, 2014. See the correction statement.

Background

The Northwest Power and Conservation Council’s 2009 amendments to the Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program call for a regular system of independent and timely science reviews of the Fish Passage Center’s (FPC) analytical products. These reviews include evaluations of the Comparative Survival Study’s draft annual reports. The Independent Scientific Advisory Board’s (ISAB) reviews began four years ago with the evaluation of the CSS’s draft 2010 Annual Report (ISAB 2010-5), followed by a review of the draft 2011 Annual Report (ISAB 2011-5), the draft 2012 Annual Report (ISAB 2012-7), and most recently a review of the draft 2013 Annual Report (ISAB 2013-4). This ISAB review of the draft 2014 CSS Annual Report is the ISAB’s fifth review of CSS annual reports in response to the Council’s 2009 Program.

Summary

This ISAB evaluation begins by suggesting topics for further CSS review, then provides comments on each chapter of the CSS Draft 2014 Annual Report, and ends with editorial suggestions. Most of the CSS's draft 2014 report is an annual update of information in previous years’ reports.

Overall, this year’s report was well done. Many of the previous reviews’ suggestions have been implemented, making current reports much easier to read and digest. Our review, therefore, focuses on new information presented. For all chapters, except Chapter 2 (Life Cycle Model), the ISAB therefore had, at most, minor concerns. However, for the new material in Chapter 2, the ISAB had significant questions and concerns about the methodology used to combine information from multiple sources, particularly the approach to combine likelihood and Bayesian paradigms. The ISAB suggests that, in the final 2014 annual report and future project documents, the authors provide additional rationale and justification for the approaches used to combine information from multiple sources. Further, results presented in Figures 2.7 onwards produced some unexplained patterns. For example, why did the models tend to consistently underestimate observed survival in freshwater and overestimate survival in the ocean? These patterns may indicate a systematic error in the models. If so, what is the cause of this, and can it be addressed?

The results of Chapter 6 (tag-effects experiment) are very preliminary. However, by the end of 2014, half of the adult production expected from this study will have returned to the Carson Hatchery. Next year’s report should also include information on the number of adults produced and the tag loss rates experienced by each tag group. As the SARs become available in future years, this should result in an important peer-reviewed publication.

Overall, the ISAB believes the CSS reports provide valuable information and analyses that are fundamental for evaluating the survival of Columbia Basin salmonids.

Suggested Topics for Further Review

(a)    Hypotheses on mechanisms regulating smolt-to-adult return rates (SARs). The previous ISAB review had several suggestions on mechanisms regulating SARs,to which the CSS response was that it was “out of scope” of their mandate. That being the case, and since the CSS reports provide much of the data necessary for investigation of these questions, the ISAB strongly recommends that the information be available in digital formats. This will allow researchers interested in mechanisms regulating SARs to have easy access to the data. With the time series now approaching 20 years for some stocks, methods such as those in Pyper et al. (2001) may be suitable to investigate correlational patterns in migration timing, in-river survival, ocean survival, and SARs among stocks over large spatial scales to infer common effects on disparate stocks.

(b)   Life-cycle modeling questions and Fish and Wildlife Program SAR objectives. The previous ISAB review provided two questions that the life-cycle model should be able to answer.

(1)    "What changes in stream productivity [salmonid productivity in rearing streams] would be required to achieve population recovery if hydrosystem survival were to remain at the status quo?"

(2)     "What changes in hydrosystem survival would be required to achieve a 20% increase in population abundance by a particular time in the future?"

The CSS response agreed that these were important questions and felt that the next iteration of the model would be able to answer at least one of the questions. However, potential problems in the current model’s implementation may preclude answering either question at this time. The ISAB believes that it is still important to answer these questions in subsequent years.

(c)    New PIT/CWT study. The current study design, described in Chapter 6, may only detect the minimal potential adverse PIT tag effects experienced by fish in the Basin. In this experiment, larger fish are tagged before smoltification and fish are allowed to recover for several months from tagging stress. However, many field studies in the Basin apply PIT-tags to migrating smolts (some as small as 60 mm) captured in the field during warm water periods and release them soon afterward. To fully appreciate the potential impacts of PIT tags on survival and to adequately link these effects to fish tagged, a study paralleling those conditions should be performed.

Topics: 
Fish and wildlife
Tags: 
ISABComparative Survival Study

ISRP 2021-05 LibbyMFWPfollow-up1June.pdf

Download the full report

Sign up for our newsletter

  •    

Contact

  • Central Office
  • Idaho Office
  • Montana Office
  • Oregon Office
  • Washington Office
  • Council Members

Social Media:

Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn Vimeo Flickr

Copyright 2022

Privacy policy Terms & Conditions Inclusion Statement